Compensation for Unlawful Decision in Amsterdam
In Amsterdam, compensation for an unlawful decision serves as an important remedy in administrative law for residents seeking financial compensation when a government decision causes damage. This applies to decisions by local authorities, such as the Municipality of Amsterdam, that fail to meet legal standards, for example, due to unauthorized actions or violations of good governance. The goal is to restore Amsterdam residents to the position they would have been in if the decision had been correct. This protection is governed by the General Administrative Law Act (Awb) and addresses government errors, such as in permitting processes in busy neighborhoods.
Legal Basis
Within Dutch administrative law, specifically relevant to Amsterdam, compensation for an unlawful decision is covered under Article 8:88 of the Awb. This states that an administrative body, such as the Municipality of Amsterdam, is liable for damage that directly results from an unlawful decision. The claim is unconditional: fault does not need to be proven, as long as the decision is unlawful and causes damage. For Amsterdam residents, this could apply to local decisions related to housing or business operations.
Article 6:162 of the Awb addresses damage during the preparation phase, but Article 8:88 forms the core. For more insight, see compensation in administrative law. Case law from the Council of State, applied by the Amsterdam District Court, illustrates this, such as in cases involving causal links in municipal permits.
What is an Unlawful Decision?
An unlawful decision in Amsterdam is a ruling by an administrative body, such as the Municipality of Amsterdam, that violates legal requirements. This includes:
- A decision made by an unauthorized body, for example, outside an official's authority.
- Conflict with laws or treaties, such as in urban planning within the city.
- Violation of good governance principles, such as the motivation principle (Article 3:46 Awb) or the duty of care (Article 3:2 Awb).
- Inadequate preparation, such as failing to consult residents in a neighborhood procedure.
The decision is deemed unlawful if it is annulled by a court, such as the Amsterdam District Court, through objection or appeal. Typical examples in Amsterdam include an unjustified building permit for a high-rise project that harms neighbors, or an erroneous denial of a business permit that leads to a local shop going bankrupt.
Types of Compensable Damage
In the Amsterdam context, compensable damage includes both financial and non-financial harm. Financial damage involves tangible losses, such as loss of income due to municipal errors. Non-financial damage, such as emotional distress from procedures, can be claimed under Article 6:106 of the Civil Code (BW) alongside the Awb, though proof is essential.
| Type of Damage | Description | Example in Amsterdam |
|---|---|---|
| Financial Damage | Direct financial losses resulting from the decision | An unlawful parking fine from the Municipality of Amsterdam causes cash flow issues and missed opportunities for a self-employed person (ZZP'er) |
| Non-Financial Damage | Non-financial disadvantages, partially compensable | An incorrect decision on a benefit leads to prolonged stress and sleep disorders for an Amsterdam resident |
| Future Damage | Plausible anticipated costs | An unlawful denial of a terrace permit delays a hospitality business in the Pijp neighborhood, resulting in measurable revenue loss |
Central to this is the causal link: damage must directly stem from the decision. Indirect effects, such as economic trends in the city, are generally not covered.
Practical Examples
Example: The Municipality of Amsterdam grants a building permit for student housing in the Jordaan without an environmental assessment, making it unlawful. This results in nuisance, causing your property value to drop by €60,000. Under Article 8:88 of the Awb, you can seek compensation from the Amsterdam District Court, including the loss in value and possible relocation costs.
Another case: A local benefits agency unlawfully terminates your social security benefit without input. You accumulate debts in Amsterdam. After a successful appeal, you can claim the lost amounts and collection costs. In 2023, the Council of State ruled in an Amsterdam case on an income error, awarding €25,000 in compensation.
Rights and Obligations of Amsterdam Residents
As a resident of Amsterdam, you have the right to:
- Full Restoration: The government, such as the Municipality of Amsterdam, must restore your position, including interest (Article 6:119 BW).
- Access to Court: File claims with the Amsterdam District Court, often alongside objections to the decision.
- Low Barriers: No court fees for the main claim, though applicable in separate proceedings; free advice is available through the Legal Aid Office in Amsterdam.
Your obligations include:
- Reporting damage promptly after the decision.
- Providing evidence, such as receipts or local appraisals.
- Minimizing damage (duty to mitigate, Article 6:96 BW).
The administrative body must handle the claim within 8 weeks, with the option to appeal to the Amsterdam District Court.
The Procedure for Compensation
The steps for Amsterdam residents:
- Objection or Appeal: Challenge the unlawful decision before the administrative court (Awb, Chapter 8), often at the Amsterdam District Court.
- Submit Damage Claim: Simultaneously or later, file a request with the administrative body (Article
Veelgestelde vragen
Wat is mijn retourrecht?
Bij online aankopen heb je 14 dagen retourrecht zonder opgaaf van reden, tenzij de wettelijke uitzonderingen gelden.
Hoe lang geldt de wettelijke garantie?
Goederen moeten minimaal 2 jaar meewerken. Defecten die binnen 6 maanden ontstaan worden verondersteld al aanwezig te zijn.
Kan ik rente eisen over schulden?
Ja, je kunt wettelijke rente eisen (momenteel ongeveer 8% per jaar) over het openstaande bedrag.
Wat kan ik doen tegen oneerlijke handelspraktijken?
Je kunt klacht indienen bij de consumentenbond, de overheid of naar de rechter gaan.
Wat is een kredietovereenkomst?
Een kredietovereenkomst regelt hoe je geld leent, wat de rente is, en hoe je dit terugbetaalt.